Order Online
You can order online! Browse our menu items and choose what you’d like to order from us.
Custom Desserts
Desserts
Our desserts are made with love and care
9" Cake - CUSTOM
All custom 9" cakes come with 2 layers so if you would like more than 2 layers, you will need to mark it in your order. As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Confetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$95.00
7" Cake - CUSTOM
All custom 7" cakes come with 2 layers so if you would like more than 2 layers, you will need to mark it in your order. As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Confetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$75.00

4" Bento Cake - CUSTOM
Each custom bento cake is two layers and includes a top shell border. As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Confetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$30.00

6 Cupcakes - CUSTOM
As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Confetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$35.00

12 Cupcakes - CUSTOM
As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Confetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation, the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$55.00
24 Cupcakes - CUSTOM
As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Confetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation, the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$90.00
Dozen Mini Cupcakes - CUSTOM
Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Funfetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$30.00

1/2 Sheet Cake
Each sheet cake will come with 2 layers. This will feed approximately 32-40 people. As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Funfetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$120.00
Full Sheet Cake
Each sheet cake will come with 2 layers. This will feed approximately 64-80 people. As a company, we do not work with fondant. If you have a design that includes fondant, we will make the design using buttercream so the design will NOT be exact. Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design and Carter's Creations will reach out for more information. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet - Strawberry - Vanilla - Chocolate - Funfetti - Red Velvet Oreo - Oreo - Lemon Depending on the consultation (up to baker's discretion), the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$205.00
6 Cookies
Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet crinkle - Sugar - Chocolate Chip - White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Depending on the consultation, the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$35.00

12 Cookies
Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet crinkle - Sugar - Chocolate Chip - White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Depending on the consultation, the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$55.00
24 Cookies
Please write a description of your idea if you are wanting a design. What constitutes a specialty flavor? Any flavor not listed here: - Red Velvet crinkle - Sugar - Chocolate Chip - White Chocolate Macadamia Nut Depending on the consultation, the price might change from what you originally ordered! Thank you!
$90.00
Specialty Cake Flavors
Desserts
Our desserts are made with love and care
Snickers 9" Cake
Each cake with have a chocolate base with roasted peanuts baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped snickers pieces on top with a salted caramel drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$75.00

Snickers 7" Cake
Each cake with have a chocolate base with roasted peanuts baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped snickers pieces on top with a salted caramel drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$65.00

Snickers 4" Bento Cake
Only comes in 1 layer. Each cake with have a chocolate base with roasted peanuts baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped snickers pieces on top with a salted caramel drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$25.00

Reese's 9" Cake
Each cake with have a chocolate base with peanut butter chips baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped Reeses pieces on top with a peanut butter drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$75.00

Reese's 7" Cake
Each cake with have a chocolate base with peanut butter chips baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped Reeses pieces on top with a peanut butter drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$65.00

Reeses 4" Bento Cake
Only comes in 1 layer. Each cake with have a chocolate base with peanut butter chips baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped Reeses pieces on top with a peanut butter drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$25.00

German Chocolate 9" Cake
Each cake with have a chocolate base made with Dutch processed cocoa powder with chocolate butter cream with the coconut pecan topping. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$65.00
German Chocolate 7" Cake
Each cake with have a chocolate base made with Dutch processed cocoa powder with chocolate butter cream with the coconut pecan topping. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$60.00
German Chocolate 4" Bento Cake
Only comes in 1 layer. Each cake with have a chocolate base made with Dutch processed cocoa powder with chocolate butter cream with the coconut pecan topping. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$25.00
Pecan Praline 9" Cake
Each cake with have a butter pecan base with shredded coconut baked into the cake with the pecan topping. No frosting on this cake. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$70.00
Pecan Praline 7" Cake
Each cake with have a butter pecan base with shredded coconut baked into the cake with the pecan topping. No frosting on this cake. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$60.00
Pecan Praline 4" Bento Cake
Only comes in 1 layer. Each cake with have a butter pecan base with shredded coconut baked into the cake with the pecan topping. No frosting on this cake. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cake.
$25.00
6 Cupcakes
Snickers: Each cake with have a chocolate base with roasted peanuts baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped snickers pieces on top with a salted caramel drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Reese's: Each cake with have a chocolate base with peanut butter chips baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped Reeses pieces on top with a peanut butter drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. German Chocolate: Each cake with have a chocolate base made with Dutch processed cocoa powder with chocolate butter cream with the coconut pecan topping. Pecan Praline: Each cake with have a butter pecan base with shredded coconut baked into the cake with the pecan topping. No frosting on this cake. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cupcake.
$35.00

12 Cupcakes
Snickers: Each cake with have a chocolate base with roasted peanuts baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped snickers pieces on top with a salted caramel drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Reese's: Each cake with have a chocolate base with peanut butter chips baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped Reeses pieces on top with a peanut butter drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. German Chocolate: Each cake with have a chocolate base made with Dutch processed cocoa powder with chocolate butter cream with the coconut pecan topping. Pecan Praline: Each cake with have a butter pecan base with shredded coconut baked into the cake with the pecan topping. No frosting on this cake. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cupcake.
$55.00

24 Cupcakes
Snickers: Each cake with have a chocolate base with roasted peanuts baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped snickers pieces on top with a salted caramel drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. Reese's: Each cake with have a chocolate base with peanut butter chips baked into the cake, cream cheese buttercream, chopped Reeses pieces on top with a peanut butter drizzle. ONLY comes with cream cheese buttercream. German Chocolate: Each cake with have a chocolate base made with Dutch processed cocoa powder with chocolate butter cream with the coconut pecan topping. Pecan Praline: Each cake with have a butter pecan base with shredded coconut baked into the cake with the pecan topping. No frosting on this cake. Any substitutions or changes will immediately become a CUSTOM cupcake.
$90.00

Weddings
Intimate Package (Up to 50 Guests)
Intimate Package
This package will include: - Wedding day delivery and set up and with venue provided resources - One custom 7" 3 layer cake for bride and groom with custom cake stand and cutter - Cupcakes for corresponding amount of guests (up to 4 different flavors) with wedding date edible image - Other goodies which include: * Brownies * Cakesicles * Cookies * Dessert Bar (i.e lemon, cheesecake)
$1,300.00
Forever Package (55-100 Guests)
Forever Package
This package will include: - Wedding day delivery and set up and with venue provided resources - One custom 9" 3 layer cake for bride and groom with custom cake stand and cutter - Cupcakes for corresponding amount of guests (up to 4 different flavors) with wedding date edible image - Other goodies which include: * Brownies * Cakesicles * Cookies * Dessert Bar (i.e lemon, cheesecake)
$2,150.00
Happily Ever After Package (105+ Guests)
Happily Ever After Package
This package will include: - Wedding day delivery and set up and with venue provided resources - One custom 2 tier (7" on top of 9" with 3 layers each and up to 2 flavors) cake for bride and groom with custom cake stand and cutter - Cupcakes for corresponding amount of guests (up to 4 different flavors) with wedding date edible image - Other goodies which include: * Brownies * Cakesicles * Cookies * Dessert Bar (i.e lemon, cheesecake)
$3,300.00
